FIVE players who should be axed by Tottenham in January

The January transfer window has never been an ideal time to buy players, Âbut it does give Premier League clubs an important opportunity to offload some deadwood before the season’s final run-in.Something Tottenham boss Mauricio Pochettino should bear in mind – his Tottenham side are currently caught in transition and there’s a number of players falling by the wayside, struggling to fit into the Argentine’s energetic philosophy.Getting rid of some fringe players will free up funds for more recruitment in the summer too, and thus, here’s a list of FIVE players the Lilywhites could look to axe when the winter window opens.

[ffc-gallery]CLICK ON POCHETTINO TO REVEAL ALL

[/ffc-gallery]

BENOIT ASSOU-EKOTTO

In Ben Davies, Danny Rose, Kyle Naughton, Jan Vertonghen and Benoit Assou-Ekotto, Spurs possess five players capable of playing at left-back. No club in the world needs five potential No.3’s – an issue the Lilywhites will surely look to address when the transfer window reopens.

And in regards to potential departures, the Cameroon international is by far the likeliest candidate.

He recently received a three-match ban for supporting Nicolas Anelka’s infamous ‘Quinelle’ gesture on Twitter:

That translates as “I congratulate you on your beautiful quinelle” – something a large contingent of the White Hart Lane faithful still rather shocked and appalled by, considering the salute’s anti-Semitic connotations.

But even if he was available, the 30 year-old wouldn’t be part of Mauricio Pochettino’s match day plans; despite having the early rounds of the Europa League to issue fringe players as much time as possible, Assou-Ekotto is yet to feature competitively under the Argentine, having also been left out of Tottenham’s 25-man Premier League squad.

Indeed, after a rather forgettable loan spell in the Championship with QPR last season, it’s alleged Spurs offered the defender out on a free transfer during the latter stages of the summer window:

But with a viable suitor yet to emerge for Spurs stalwart, who has made 155 top flight appearances for the north London side, Tottenham may be stuck with him until the summer when his contract expires. This headbutt on Cameroon team-mate Benjamin Moukandjo at the World Cup certainly hasn’t improved Assou-Ekotto’s limited market appeal: //www.youtube.com/embed/d_MtcEFnVdw?rel=0

Likely selling fee: £0

Roberto Soldado

How long can this sorry state of affairs go on for? Tottenham splashed out a club-record £26million on Roberto Soldado, but the Spain striker has found just six Premier League goals since – four of which were from the penalty spot. There’s certainly been moments of brilliance along the way, giving a glimpse into what the former Valencia star is capable of under the right circumstances:

//www.youtube.com/embed/aI_HGuZbPO8?rel=0 But measuring in at 5 foot 10, bearing no particular pace or power, Soldado has always looked out of sorts with the Premier League and even more so, Tottenham’s style of play. In 2011/2012 and 2012/13, the Lilywhites recorded the second-most shots per match of any Premier League side, 47% and 56% respectively of which were from outside the box, yet the Spaniard could count could count his amount of goals from over 18 yards for Los Che on one hand. With Spurs seemingly keen to recoup as much of their investment as possible before the 29 year-old loses all resale value, rumours liking him with a move away from White Hart Lane are not hard to find:

And having issued Soldado even less appearances than 21 year-old Harry Kane this season, Mauricio Pochettino is unlikely to stand in the way of a January departure. Likely selling fee:£12-£15million

Andros Townsend

Andros Townsend was labelled as England’s new hero when he netted this stunning strike against Montenegro to secure his country’s place at the World Cup last October: //www.youtube.com/embed/BAkOjFq1_Tc?rel=0

But based on his woeful form since, the 23 year-old has already experienced the highest point of his career. Indeed, last season he took 56 attempts at goal, yet, with only one actually hitting the target – believe it or not, a misguided cross which somehow looped it’s way over Aston Villa’s Brad Guzan – his conversion rate was a pathetic 2%.

The kind of player who appears to revel in the fact he can nearly score from anywhere on the pitch, despite never actually finding the net, Townsend’s become a huge frustration for the fans and seemingly Mauricio Pochettino, who has issued him just two substitute appearances in the Premier League thus far. The Lilywhites allegedly tried to offload the former QPR loanee during the summer, suggesting a swap deal for Southampton’s Jay Rodriguez, and they’ll likely attempt to rekindle this deal in January.

The winger may feel he needs a change of scene too, with Roy Hodgson warning that without regular game time, Townsend won’t be selected for future England squads:

Likely transfer fee:£7million-£10million, or a sum to that value taken off Jay Rodriguez’ price-tag.

AARON LENNON

Another winger who’s Tottenham career could be coming to an abrupt end – according to reports this morning, the Lilywhites are set to sell Aaron Lennon:

As the headline claims, the 27 year-old doesn’t want to leave, but he’s only mustered up one Premier League start under Mauricio Pochettino and is unlikely to see more game-time with Erik Lamela now beginning to find form.

Lennon has been an incredible servant to the Lilywhites – he’s made 353 appearances for them since moving to north London from Leeds United way back in 2005. Here’s a look at some of his highlights for Spurs:

//www.youtube.com/embed/m_o-6PvL8qw?rel=0

But after nine years, Lennon’s Tottenham tenure has likely run its course. In terms of potential buyers, QPR and Stoke were both linked on deadline day and could reignite their interest in the new year.

Likely transfer fee:£6million-£9million

Moussa Dembele

Football – Sunderland v Tottenham Hotspur – Barclays Premier League – Stadium of Light – 14/15 , 13/9/14Tottenham’s Mousa DembeleMandatory Credit: Action Images / Ed SykesEDITORIAL USE ONLY. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or “live” services. Online in-match use limited to 45 images, no video emulation. No use in betting, games or single club/league/player publications. Please contact your account representative for further details.

Powerhouse midfielder Moussa Dembele has muscled his way back into Tottenham’s starting Xi in recent weeks, having spent much of last season on the peripheries of the squad.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

But reports claim Everton are planning a January swoop:

And having never really replicated the form that earned him a £15million move from Fulham to White Hart Lane in summer 2012, as shown in the video below, the Lilywhites could be convinced into cashing in on the Belgium international.

//www.youtube.com/embed/xCZotD1jC9c?rel=0

Especially considering Spurs are hardly short of imposing, physical figures – like Dembele- in the middle of the park. Paulinho, Etienne Capoue, Nabil Bentaleb and Benjamin Stambouli all fit that mould too.

Likely transfer fee:£8million-£10million

[ffc-quiz ]

[ad_pod id=’footballfancast’ align=’center’]

Liverpool FC youngster wants more after ‘special’ debut

Liverpool FC’s young midfielder Conor Coady can’t wait to make more appearances for the Reds following his first team debut against Anzhi Makhachkala last night.

The 19-year-old was one of several youngsters who travelled to Moscow for the Europa League Group A clash.

And the Liverpool-born youngster is eager to build on what he has described as a “really special moment” and become a Liverpool regular in the future.

He told Liverpool’s official website: “It was fantastic and I enjoyed every minute of it.

“It was a big night for me and my family. It is every boy’s dream to play for Liverpool. You have to be patient, bide your time and work hard at training. I have been waiting a long time for this day and it was really special to get out there and play.

“I put my all into it and I was made up to make my debut. I was happy with the way I played and I thought all the boys did well. Hopefully it is the first appearance of many for me.”

Coady went on to praise his manager Brendan Rodgers and admitted that, despite making his dream debut, he was disappointed to be on the losing side.

“I thought we were a bit unlucky not to get anything from the game. We sat there, competed with them and I thought we were fantastic tactically,” he continued.

“We are just disappointed not to get a result, but we will bounce back from this and become better.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

“It is fantastic to play under Brendan. He has given a lot of us young lads games this season and it is great he has shown faith.”

[post_link url=”https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/liverpool/liverpool-terrific-despite-defeat-says-rodgers,https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/liverpool/do-football-clubs-do-enough-to-protect-them,https://www.footballfancast.com/football-blogs/the-death-of-legends-within-football,https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/would-a-decrease-in-football-prices-really-improve-things,https://www.footballfancast.com/image-gallery/the-top-20-hottest-premier-league-wags-of-all-time ” target=”_blank” type=”grid”]

[ad_pod id=’tv’ align=’center’]

Theo Walcott to snub United for Arsenal extension

Theo Walcott is set to snub an approach from Manchester United to sign a new deal with Arsenal, according to reports from the Daily Mail.

The attacker’s future has been in doubt for some time now, with his current contract set to expire at the end of the season.

He was believed to be demanding a pay increase and guarantees surrounding a position as the club’s first-choice centre-forward, requests which were initially rejected by the Gunners.

This alerted Manchester United boss Sir Alex Ferguson, who is said to be keen to take the England international to Old Trafford.

However, Walcott is reportedly willing to extend his stay in North London, with a compromise having been made between himself and manager Arsene Wenger.

The Frenchman is believed to have reconsidered the player’s importance within the squad and is happy to press ahead with a new contract, which could be signed before Sunday’s clash with Manchester City.

Walcott’s recent form has seen him become the club’s top goal scorer with 14 efforts in all competitions – eight of which have come in the Premier League.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

This has furthered his claims to play as the focal point of the attack, especially with summer signing Olivier Giroud struggling to adapt to English football.

[cat_link cat=”arsenal” type=”grid”]

Southampton v Liverpool – Team Line-Ups

Liverpool travel to Southampton today on the back of a superb 3-2 victory over high-flying Tottenham last weekend.

A result like that one at Anfield will have Brendan Rodgers’ side believing a top-four finish is still achievable, despite trailing fourth by seven points going in to this weekend’s fixture.

Southampton are far from safety as they lurk dangerously above the drop-zone and their current form of one win in their last eight Premier League games shows they still have a lot to do to maintain their top-flight status.

Here’s how they’ll line up at St. Mary’s:

Southampton: Boruc, Clyne, Yoshida, Hooiveld, Shaw, Schneiderlin, Cork, Lallana (c), Ramírez, Rodriguez, Lambert.

Subs: K. Davis, Fonte, S. Davis, Forren, Ward-Prowse, Guly, Puncheon.

Liverpool: Jones, Johnson, Enrique, Agger, Skrtel, Allen, Gerrard, Downing, Coutinho, Sturridge, Suarez.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Subs: Gulacsi, Wisdom, Henderson, Shelvey, Lucas, Suso, Ibe.

Follow all of today’s Premier League action below…

Live Football Blogs on FootballFanCast.com »

Capital One Cup conveyor belt is still in motion

This week heralded the return of the Capital One Cup and the third round certainly lived up to expectations. We have now grown accustomed to the annual midweek programme in September that brings us evening football under the lights, the anthemic melodies of Texas’ Inner Smile and and most importantly the future stars the competition brings to our attention.

Indeed, the League Cup has now become synonymous as a pathway through which young talents emerge, intermingle with first team regulars and look to catch the eye in the hopes of a more frequent role at first team level in the league and potential overtures in Europe. Almost like a one off audition perhaps.

It may be difficult to pin point exactly when it became fashionable for managers to utilise the League Cup as a springboard and anticipated opportunity for fans to get a sneak peak of the stars of tomorrow, but we have now grown used to scrolling through our match day programmes to find a few names draped more in mystery than instant recollection.

Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger has always made public his desire to blood younger talents in the competition and a pattern has started to emerge predominantly across the top two divisions with the many league regulars being replaced in the midweek by a cast of eager, hungry first timers hell bent on making an impression.

Over the years more and more Premier League sides and now Championship outfits alike are following the Wenger ideal by letting their precocious youngsters loose in the competition and who can blame them?

The Capital One Cup offers passionate fans a competitive environment and good old fashioned knockout football that can only be beneficial to the development of any young pro. Vociferous encouragement from the crowd and geeing up from a respected first team accomplice, is a far cry away from the ripple of applause that could be witnessed during a reserve or youth team fixture that would usually represent the surroundings for mere 20-somethings.

With this extra confidence and an understandable adrenaline rush having been given this experience it is no surprise that so many youngsters perform so well and become a first team fixture at their respective club given this initial opportunity.

With sides competing on a number of fronts including the Premier League, FA Cup and European tournaments, the Capital One Cup distinguishes itself on giving frequent first team opportunities to younger pros who wouldn’t gain as much playing time if the competition ceased to exist. Robbie Fowler, David Beckham and Steven Gerrard have all made their name in the League Cup and have gone on to achieve an impressive standing in the game.

This time last year Manchester United handed debuts to young Ezekiel Fryers and Larnell Cole in their fixture against Leeds at Elland Road, and way back in the 2003/4 campaign, a fledgling Cesc Fabregas then wearing squad number 57 scored his first ever goal for Arsenal in the League Cup in a home tie to Wolverhampton Wanderers at Highbury.

With some Premier League clubs entering the competition at the second round phase this year, there was plenty of evidence in the selected rosters that this occurrence of youth is just as prevalent as ever.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

West Ham brought on Matthias Fanimo and George Moncur in their victory against Crewe Alexandra, Aston Villa replaced Australian first teamer Chris Herd with young Irishman Graham Burke during a tie against League One Tranmere Rovers and Southampton boss Nigel Adkins saw Stevenage as the perfect location to hand opportunities to development squad members Luke Shaw, Calum Chambers and Cobey Moore.

This invaluable experience in the Capital One Cup opening phases has now become a staple part of the footballing calendar and more and more clubs are using it as the perfect and assumed opportunity to blood youth.

It is unquestionable that the Capital One Cup conveyor belt is certainly still in motion. All that is left to mystery is just who will become the young star that takes the Capital One Cup by storm this year and really makes a name for themselves.

Arsenal transfer news: Huntelaar out of Gunners’ price range

Arsenal have been dealt a blow in their pursuit of striker Klaas-Jan-Huntelaar after being told they can’t afford him by Shalke’s general manger Horst Heldt.

The Dutch striker is out of contract in the summer and Wenger is still looking to cover the loss of star striker Robin van Persie last season. However Heldt believes the Gunners will be priced out of a move.

“There have been no offers or any sign of Klaas-Jan leaving. If someone comes to us six months before the expiry date, and has a lot of money, we will deal with it. But from Arsenal circles we hear there is no money anyway,” Heldt told the Sun.

The under pressure Gunners boss has looked increasingly frustrated in recent weeks, promising his own fans that funds would be available to strengthen the squad after the club secured a new £150million sponsorship deal with Emirates last week. It is believed that he was hoping a £6million bid in January would be enough to sign the striker.

Heldt’s comments suggest Wenger may need to increase his valuation for 29-year-old Huntelaar who scored in both games against Arsenal for Schalke in this season’s Champions League group stages.

Huntelaar has been a revelation in Germany and notched up 29 goals in 32 Bundesliga games last season. His contract situation and the fact that he could leave on a free in the summer if a deal isn’t agreed in January could however work in Wenger’s favour in terms of striking a cheap deal.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

[cat_link cat=”arsenal” type=”grid”]

More luck than judgement at Tottenham?

Last night embodied a lot of what being a Tottenham fan is all about. A European night under the lights, a journey into the unknown and 90 minutes of heart wrenching emotion; fans wouldn’t have it any other way would they?

It may not have been the glamour of the Champions League, but European football is special for a club like Spurs, and victory last night will hopefully be a catalyst now for a further assault on the Premier League top four. But for many Spurs fans last night did little to allay their fears and to convince them that Tim Sherwood is the right man to push them forward.

In cup football it rarely matters how you make it through, it is all about keeping your hopes live, but for a Spurs side looking for a return to the stylish football of old this just wasn’t it. Spurs have been lacklustre in recent weeks, and edging past what should have been simple opposition in Dnipro is no great achievement. Many were quick to write Dnipro off as complete fodder, but even so Spurs should be convincingly beating what are only a half decent European side.

In fact if it hadn’t have been a bit of good fortune Spurs may well have been facing the reality of a shock last 32 exit from the competition. In the first leg Dnipro could easily have been a couple of goals ahead, and had Soldado been rightfully sent off in the return we may well have been looking at a different outcome.

People may just say, so what? Spurs got through and that is all that matters.

They’d be right because in the end safe passage is all that matters, but for Sherwood’s side as a whole it clearly doesn’t bode well.

In fact before the sending off last night it didn’t really look like Spurs were going to be able to muster anything apart from a speculative set piece. It was yet another case of lots of talented cogs simply not clicking, players getting in the way of one another and simply not combining effectively. Man for man Spurs should have won that game with ease, but if anything it was Juande Ramos’ Dnipro that looked the more like scoring.

Most worry of all for Spurs fans was Sherwood’s continued inability to influence a match. More preoccupied with the 4th official and a rolling argument about the multi ball system, he seemed oblivious to the tactical inadequacies of his side.

The obvious change was to put another winger on and try to stretch Dnipro. The early exchanges either saw Eriksen plow down the middle or Townsend run into a barrage of defenders down the right.

But the game itself turned on a piece of individual brilliance, and a moment of idiocy from Zozulya and petulance from Vertonghen. Sherwood like so many games before has failed to anything than cheerlead, and if that’s what being a manger is all about I’m sure a lot of us would be quite successful.

Spurs fans have a right to celebrate what was both an impressive and dramatic comeback, but when the dust settles they will probably realise that they got away with one here. But the concern is that Sherwood doesn’t see it like this, and just isn’t learning, speaking after the game he said:

”We’ve come out and done it, won the tie, and we’re looking forward to the next game on Sunday. You’re only as good as your last game. Today we were very good. Last Sunday we weren’t very good”

Spurs were gutsy, but I certainly wouldn’t say they were very good. Hopefully what Sherwood thinks and says to the press are two wholly different things because from my point of view last night showed that very little is being learn by the young manager.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Next up is Benfica, a true test of Spurs’ European pedigree and one where hopefully the club can go a long way to proving their doubters wrong.

Is it a time for joyous celebration at Spurs or maybe time to just appreciate the fact that they  got a bit lucky?

Click below to watch the Capital One Cup final for FREE

Crocked Hammers ace will not rush back

Ricardo Vaz Te says that he will not return from injury to the West Ham side too quickly, and will make sure he is back to full fitness first.

The winger became injured with a dislocated shoulder at the Arsenal game earlier this month. Vaz Te had started the season well for Sam Allardyce’s side, appearing seven times for the Hammers, with one goal and two assists.

However, he had to have shoulder surgery, ruling Vaz Te out for approximately three months.

Vaz Te has now had keyhole surgery and he has started rehabilitation. He said to West Ham’s official website that now has “four week during which there is nothing much I can do to, so I just have to make sure I relax and look after myself.”

He added: “I have a week off to either go home or simply chill out and relax. Then I’ll come back for two weeks and that completes the first four weeks, which are just steady recovery. After that, I will begin to increase my workload for the next six weeks. After that, the socket involved should be totally healed and only until then can I push on. Until then, the work is mild and I just have to relax and make sure I get the movement back.”

Vaz Te is not a stranger to being injured for a lengthy period, having already suffered a knee ligament injury in the past. He said that he has learnt from past experience, and he knows he has to have patience in the recovery process. He said: “If you don’t heal properly then you are never right and are always playing catch-up. I have to make sure I fully relax and let the socket and everything heal and only after that can I actually push. Overall, they have given me 12 weeks, but obviously if I can return earlier I will do but only if it is safe to do so. I just have to concentrate on recovering properly and making sure that, when I get back, I am fully fit rather than halfway there and break down again. It is frustrating I have to put my plans on hold. I have got a lot of things I want to achieve, obviously.”

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Vaz Te scored the goal that brought West Ham back into the Premier League for this season.

[post_link url=” https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/the-15-great-polar-opposites-within-football, https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/football-fancast-paints-a-picture-of-the-modern-footballer, https://www.footballfancast.com/football-blogs/top-players-in-europe-who-would-be-the-perfect-fit-in-the-premier-league,https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/the-football-quarterbacks-and-their-role-within-the-game,https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/arsenal/the-ideal-role-for-theo-walcott” target=”_blank” type=”grid”]

England set to move to new suppliers

England’s kit looks set to undergo a massive revamp as Nike have taken over Umbro’s contract to be their official kit supplier, according to the Daily Mail.

It ends the sportswear company’s long association with FA, which has existed since the 1950s as well as the current £20 million-a-year deal.

Umbro’s contract with the England national team originally ran until 2018, but a new Nike-designed away strip could be available for fans as early as next spring.

The deal appeared to allow Umbro to continue supplying shirts for the team, despite Nike’s £285 million takeover of the firm in 2007.

The American company’s supposedly lucrative deal is likely to have turned the heads of FA officials, especially as Umbro are now facing an uncertain future.

It is news which looks set to anger the more consumer-minded fans, especially as a new Umbro-designed home kit was only released in February.

The FA have refused to comment on the story, but it is understood that officials were ready to formally announce the plans last week.

Manchester City are also set to follow suit and change from Umbro to Nike,  something which local rivals Manchester United did ten years earlier, as their £6 million-a- year deal signed in 2009, will be overtaken.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Mancini’s men will be kitted out by Nike from next season, ending their current 10-year deal.

[ad_pod id=’dfp-mpu’ align=’right’]

Do their goalscoring exploits actually mask their flaws?

Everyone loves Fantasy Football, it dominates our thoughts the closer we get to a new Premier League season, we can spend hours pouring over the information before we settle on our side. A key component of this is picking players that will score goals in positions that don’t normally rely upon them, such as a goalscoring centre-half or full-back. With this in mind, do we overrate goalscoring defenders? Ando do we let them off lightly when it becomes to their defensive deficiencies because they happen to be good at finding the back of the net? Fantasy Football has a lot to answer for….

I’m a sucker for goalscoring defenders may I just say begin with. My fantasy football teams at school always, always included Everton’s David Unsworth (45 goals in 445 games) and Leicester’s Matt Elliott (70 goals in 589 games), with the occasional nod to Julian Dicks (55 goals in 379 games). They were invaluable, the poorness of the defences they played in was completely counter-acted by the points they’d get me for their inevitable solid five-goal a season return. Heck, I even had Gary Cahill (21 goals in 234 games) and Mats Hummels (17 goals in 162 games) in my Euro 2012 side until injury cruelly robbed me of the former, while the other never bloody scored.

The short but simple fact is that everyone loves a goalscoring defender. We love the unexpected nature of their forward forays up the pitch. We love the fact that because they can clear the ball a whopping great distance means, this all of a sudden qualifies them as a free-kick expert. However, does this mean that we shy away from criticising them for doing the job that they are actually paid to do, which is defend?

According to the Premier League’s own player performance index, Arsenal’s Thomas Vermaelen was the 58th best player in the top flight last term. His season was interrupted by injury on ocassion, but he still managed to complete 29 league games, scoring six goals in the process. He made 29 clearances, 11 blocks and helped his side to 11 clean sheets during his time in the starting eleven. At the other end of the pitch, though, he finished the campaign with 37 shots, five crosses and one assist – not too bad at all for a centre-back it has to be said, certainly more than a lot of the deadwood currently at the club are capable of (I’m looking at you Park Chu-Young and Marouane Chamakh).

On the face of things it would seem like he had a very good season, would it not? However, Vermaelen has developed a worrying propensity to get dragged out of position, as was clearly in evidence during the 3-3 draw against Norwich last season at home, where he was quite frankly all over the place. He was far from his best throughout the course of the campaign, with partner Laurent Koscielny the superior partner for the most part.

Upon arriving in England, it was noted that at just 6ft tall, he looked a tad on the short side to be a commanding centre-half, but his aerial ability is one of his greatest strengths and plays a large part in his prowess in front of goal. To talk about Vermaelen in terms of criticism, he rarely comes in for any flak considering his poor positioning. He’s quick on the ground, mobile and decent on the ball, so anything that isn’t seen as a positive is conveniently glossed over.

Jonny Evans last season was the main beneficiary of Nemanja Vidic’s season-ending knee injury, going on to play 27 times for Manchester United as they were pipped to the post for the title by bitter rivals Manchester City. He has often been made out to be a scapegoat by many fans, yet he managed 30 blocks, 56 clearances and 16 clean sheets in less games than Vermaelen. The crucial difference is he doesn’t offer anything going forward and any mistake at the back is magnified tenfold, whereas with Vermaelen it is not.

We often gloss over the glaring weaknesses in a defender if they manage to chip in with the odd goal. John Arne Riise had an excellent first few years at Liverpool, but then spent his last two seasons trying to replicate his goal against Tottenham from 40 yards out every single time he crossed the halfway line. Matt Taylor suffers from a similar flaw. To call it frustrating to watch would be an understatement, yet at Fulham last season, shorn of his pace at 31 years of age, he looked a much better defender than his final couple of years at Anfield, but he had no goals in 40 appearances to show for it, despite his best efforts at breaking his duck.

Taye Taiwo managed to score 23 goals in 253 games at Marseille, where his job was to bound beyond the winger down the left-hand flank and he became a key part of their style of play. He then moved to AC Milan but struggled, as it seemed nobody actually checked first if he was any good at this defending lark before being farmed out to QPR on loan in the second half of last season. He’s full of energy, built like a tank but seems oddly unsure of where to actually stand when he’s on the back foot and is hugely susceptible to a ball played in behind him, a common occurrence for pacy full-backs these days.

Andreas Granqvist managed to bag 11 goals for Groningen in the Eredivise the year before last, but Wigan fans will remember a defender frightfully out of kilter with the pace of the top flight, yet AC Milan and Inter are rumoured to be interested in the Swede this summer after a decent first year at Genoa in Italy. It’s all about striking the right balance.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Ian Harte, Marco Materazzi, Daniel van Buyten, Naldo, Alex all made headlines for their goalscoring exploits in their respctive leagues over the years but they all have obvious flaws to their game. It’s when the goals become solely what they are remembered for that you start to worry and Vermaelen is in danger of falling into that trap.

The likes of Brazilian centre-half Juan, Sami Hyypia, Robert Huth, Sergio Ramos and Diego Lugano are all remembered for their defending first and foremost, with their attacking prowess just an added bonus, which is why they’re quite rightly regarded as superior players to the aforementioned list above, Vermaelen aside.

It may not solely be the result of Fantasy Football, but something has become distorted along the way – goalscoring defenders are judged on their abilities further forward just as much as they are on their ability to stem an attack at the back and that’s a worrying trap to fall into. We should treat the goalscoring defender as a positive, they bring unexpected joy to the terraces and every side likes to have one in their side, but they have to be good enough defenders first, otherwise, that’s a slippery slope to head down.

Game
Register
Service
Bonus